Commercial failures in Indian cinema frequently result in critical reviews and a subsequent decline in box office earnings. These films, often characterized by underwhelming performances in comparison to anticipated outcomes, represent a significant aspect of the film industry. Factors contributing to poor reception can vary and often include poor scriptwriting, directorial choices, or casting issues. An example might be a film touted for its star power that ultimately struggles to connect with audiences or critics.
The study of unsuccessful films provides valuable insights into the dynamics of the Indian film industry. Analyzing these failures reveals patterns in audience preferences, the effectiveness of marketing strategies, and the evolving tastes of viewers. Historical context also plays a role; shifts in cultural trends, technological advancements, and emerging competition within the film industry all contribute to the understanding of commercial outcomes. Examining such films can inform future productions and refine industry practices, contributing to a more robust and adaptable film landscape. This also facilitates the exploration of various elements affecting box office performance, such as production value, promotion, and cultural relevance.
This analysis will explore a range of unsuccessful films, examining the factors that led to their poor reception. It will then delve into the broader implications for the Indian film industry, discussing the role of audience expectations, critical reviews, and market trends in shaping the fortunes of Bollywood productions.
Flop Movies in Bollywood
Analyzing unsuccessful Bollywood films provides critical insights into the complexities of the industry. Understanding the factors contributing to box office failures is essential for a comprehensive understanding of the film landscape.
- Poor Scriptwriting
- Directorial Choices
- Casting Issues
- Marketing Failures
- Audience Disconnect
- Cultural Relevance
- Production Quality
- Star Power Miscalculation
Unsuccessful films often result from a confluence of issues. Poor scriptwriting, for example, can lead to a lack of engagement with audiences. Inaccurate casting choices might compromise the film's performance. Marketing failures, particularly in reaching the target audience, can be a significant factor. Often, a perceived disconnect between the film's themes and the contemporary cultural landscape can be a crucial reason for failure. A film lacking in production quality may lose viewers. Even films relying heavily on star power can underperform if the audience is unimpressed with the film's substance. The interplay of these factors is rarely straightforward, revealing the multifaceted nature of cinematic success.
1. Poor Scriptwriting
Substandard screenplays frequently contribute to box office failures in Bollywood. A poorly conceived narrative, weak character development, or a lack of compelling plot points can result in a film that fails to resonate with audiences. Analysis of such scripts often reveals systemic issues in the storytelling process.
- Lack of Originality and Uniqueness
Many films, despite their star casts, underperform due to a lack of originality in their narrative structure. Repetitive plotlines, predictable character arcs, and uninspired storylines fail to provide new experiences for viewers. This lack of freshness and novelty can alienate audiences, regardless of technical aspects or star power.
- Inadequate Character Development
Characters lacking depth and relatable motivations can lead to an audience disconnection. A failure to establish compelling character backstories, motivations, and development results in flat or unsympathetic figures. This lack of emotional engagement hinders audience connection.
- Poor Pacing and Structure
A poorly structured narrative with inconsistent pacing can significantly impact a film's impact. A film might have excellent individual scenes but suffer from an overall disjointed or slow-paced plot. The failure to create a dynamic flow and structure can leave audiences feeling unengaged.
- Weak Dialogue and Dialogue Delivery
Dialogues that lack wit, originality, and authenticity can make a film seem generic or clichd. Poorly written or delivered dialogue can disconnect viewers from the characters and story. This often leads to a lack of emotional connection.
These factors, individually or collectively, contribute significantly to the failure of a film. The quality of the screenplay is often the foundation upon which a film's success or failure is built. Without a strong and well-crafted screenplay, the film risks falling flat with audiences, leading to poor reviews and low box office numbers.
2. Directorial Choices
Directorial decisions significantly impact a film's success or failure. A director's choices concerning visual style, pacing, character portrayal, and thematic approach can either resonate with audiences or lead to a disconnection. These choices, when flawed or misaligned with audience preferences, are frequently linked to poor box office performance in Bollywood.
- Pacing and Rhythm
Inconsistent pacing can disrupt the narrative flow. A film that oscillates between rapid-fire scenes and overly drawn-out sequences can leave the audience feeling disengaged. A lack of rhythm and pacing creates uneven viewing experience. For example, a film might open with great energy but then lose momentum, impacting the overall engagement with the story.
- Visual Style and Cinematography
Visually uninspired or inconsistent cinematography can diminish the impact of a film. A lack of visual creativity, repetitive camera angles, or inappropriate use of color palettes can negatively influence the aesthetic appeal. A movie lacking visual interest might struggle to capture the attention of viewers.
- Character Portrayal and Development
Unsatisfying characterizations or inconsistent portrayals can result in the audience not connecting with the characters. A failure to develop characters with depth, nuance, or relatable qualities can leave audiences indifferent to the story's progression and outcomes. In some cases, the characters might seem unrealistic or underdeveloped, making the narrative feel hollow.
- Thematic Choices and Narrative Structure
Thematic misalignment or inappropriate interpretations of the narrative can lead to a disconnect with the audience. A film that tackles complex or sensitive themes inadequately or in a way that clashes with the cultural context can negatively impact the film's reception. A poorly developed or unclear thematic statement often contributes to the failure of a movie.
These varied, yet interconnected, directorial choices significantly impact the success of a film. A poor understanding of how these elements work togetherin establishing audience connection and narrative impactoften results in a commercial failure. The quality of directorial choices and their alignment with audience expectations are crucial factors determining whether a film resonates with the public, ultimately impacting box office figures.
3. Casting Issues
Casting choices frequently play a pivotal role in the success or failure of Bollywood films. Inaccurate or inappropriate casting decisions can negatively affect a film's reception, often contributing to poor box office results. A mismatch between a performer and the character's requirements can lead to audiences not connecting with the film's narrative, regardless of other merits. Casting issues are a significant component in understanding commercial failures.
The impact of casting choices extends beyond simple aesthetics. A miscast actor can undermine the credibility of a character, diminishing the emotional impact of the narrative. If the audience struggles to accept the portrayal, it can diminish the film's overall appeal. Consider the critical reception and box office performance of films where the chosen actors were deemed ill-suited to the roles. In some cases, the perceived lack of chemistry between characters can diminish audience engagement. For example, if the audience does not find the on-screen characters believable or appealing due to the acting, the film's prospects are negatively impacted. Conversely, casting the right actor can enhance a film's appeal, generating a strong emotional response and fostering a connection with audiences.
Understanding the connection between casting issues and commercial failure offers valuable insights into audience preferences and expectations within the Indian film industry. It highlights the importance of careful consideration of actors' suitability for specific roles. Production teams should prioritize the casting of performers whose talent and persona align effectively with the demands of their respective roles. Such a focus can lead to the creation of more compelling narratives and films better received by audiences, thus influencing future casting decisions and contributing to a more successful filmmaking practice. This understanding is crucial for improving future casting decisions, potentially leading to a higher likelihood of box office success. The avoidance of miscasting is therefore paramount in the pursuit of commercial triumph in Bollywood.
4. Marketing Failures
Effective marketing is crucial for the success of any film, particularly in a competitive market like Bollywood. A failure to effectively reach and engage the target audience can significantly impact a film's box office performance, often leading to its categorization as a "flop." Marketing strategies, encompassing pre-release promotions, publicity, and distribution channels, must align with the film's target demographics and thematic elements for maximum effectiveness. Inadequate or poorly executed marketing campaigns can result in the film falling short of expectations, failing to generate sufficient interest and subsequently underperforming at the box office.
Several factors contribute to marketing failures in Bollywood. Inadequate targeting strategies that fail to resonate with the intended audience can lead to a missed connection. Insufficient pre-release buzz creation and promotion can result in a lack of anticipation and excitement surrounding the film. Poorly conceived marketing campaigns or insufficient use of relevant media platforms can contribute to a muted response and low awareness, ultimately hindering box office revenue. A lack of impactful promotional materials, unclear messaging, and inconsistent execution across various channels can create confusion and a lack of impact. Poor timing of the marketing campaign relative to competitor releases can also be a critical factor. The failure to understand and engage with current cultural trends and preferences can also hinder effective outreach.
Real-world examples illustrate the impact of marketing failures. Films with strong storylines and talented casts have struggled at the box office due to inadequate promotion, highlighting the significance of effective marketing. Conversely, films with average to below-average content have sometimes achieved unexpected success due to meticulous marketing, highlighting the potent role that strategic marketing can play. This demonstrates the essential role that comprehensive and well-targeted marketing strategies play in shaping the public perception and thus the commercial success of a film. Understanding and mitigating marketing failures are essential components in the ongoing evolution and refinement of Bollywood filmmaking strategies.
In conclusion, marketing failures are a crucial factor in the categorization of some Bollywood films as flops. Careful consideration of target audience segmentation, pre-release buzz creation, and consistent messaging across all platforms are essential elements of successful marketing strategies. A clear understanding of the interplay between marketing initiatives and box office performance can significantly contribute to informed decision-making within the Bollywood film industry. By analyzing and rectifying past marketing failures, the film industry can enhance its overall success rate and create more effective promotional strategies. This, in turn, facilitates a more substantial and engaging film-viewing experience for audiences and fosters a more robust industry structure.
5. Audience Disconnect
A significant factor contributing to the failure of many Bollywood films is a disconnect between the film's content and the expectations or preferences of the target audience. This disconnect manifests in various ways, ultimately leading to a lack of engagement and, consequently, poor box office results. Understanding the nuances of this disconnect is crucial for filmmakers seeking to create successful productions.
- Cultural Relevance and Sensitivity
Films that fail to resonate with contemporary cultural sensibilities, or that misrepresent cultural nuances, often experience significant audience disconnect. A failure to recognize evolving social norms, address sensitive topics appropriately, or reflect contemporary realities can alienate viewers. Films perceived as insensitive or culturally inappropriate often struggle to gain acceptance.
- Genre Expectations and Conventions
Films that deviate from established genre expectations or fail to meet audience conventions within a specific genre can encounter difficulties connecting with the target demographic. If a film misrepresents a well-established genrefor example, a romance lacking the expected tropes or an action film missing the necessary thrillsit may fail to satisfy viewers familiar with those conventions, leading to a lack of audience engagement.
- Narrative Structure and Pacing
The narrative structure and pacing of a film significantly influence audience engagement. A convoluted plot, slow pacing, or a lack of clarity in storytelling can hinder viewer comprehension and enjoyment. Audiences might find the story confusing or unengaging if the narrative doesn't flow smoothly and maintain momentum. This results in a disconnect between the film's intended narrative and the viewer's desired engagement.
- Character Development and Relatability
Unlikeable or underdeveloped characters can impede a film's ability to connect with viewers. Characters lacking depth or motivation, or exhibiting behaviors audiences find unrealistic or unsympathetic, fail to form a meaningful connection with the audience. Ultimately, audiences lose interest and engagement in a film where characters are not well-developed or do not represent relatable qualities.
These factors, when combined, illustrate the complexity of audience disconnect and its impact on film success in Bollywood. By failing to meet audience expectations in terms of cultural relevance, genre fidelity, narrative structure, and character portrayal, a film can experience a significant disconnect, ultimately hindering its potential for commercial success. The successful filmmaker must understand and cater to the expectations of their target audience to bridge this gap and create a connection that translates into positive box office results.
6. Cultural Relevance
Cultural relevance is a critical factor in the success of Bollywood films. A film's ability to resonate with the diverse audience it aims to reach hinges significantly on its understanding and reflection of prevailing cultural values, beliefs, and trends. Failure to address these aspects can lead to a disconnect between the film and its intended audience, frequently resulting in a commercial failure.
- Misinterpretation of Social Norms
Films that misinterpret or inadequately represent contemporary social norms risk alienating significant segments of the audience. For example, a film portraying outdated gender roles or presenting insensitive portrayals of minority communities could face criticism and negative reception. Audiences may perceive such depictions as unrealistic, offensive, or simply out of touch, leading to a diminished connection with the narrative and a consequent impact on box office figures.
- Lack of Sensitivity to Regional Variations
Bollywood's reach extends across diverse regions with unique cultural nuances. A failure to acknowledge these variations, or a portrayal that generalizes or stereotypes particular regional customs, can result in negative audience reactions. Films overlooking these specific regional contexts can fail to connect with specific target demographics, leading to reduced viewership in the affected areas. A film's ability to adapt and reflect the specificities of different regional traditions is vital to its widespread appeal.
- Ignoring Current Trends and Issues
Films that remain detached from the current socio-political climate often fail to engage contemporary audiences. Addressing relevant contemporary issues and themes can deepen a film's connection with viewers who identify with such topics. Ignoring critical contemporary issues can result in a film appearing outdated or irrelevant, thus failing to generate the desired connection. A film that avoids or underplays critical societal conversations might struggle to resonate with audiences and thus underperform.
- Failure to Reflect the Diversity of the Audience
A film that fails to mirror the diverse backgrounds and perspectives of the intended audience will struggle to create a wide appeal. Films not encompassing the cultural identities and experiences of a significant portion of the population risk failing to resonate with the audience. Authentic portrayals of diverse communities and viewpoints foster a wider connection with the audience and contribute to the film's overall acceptance.
In conclusion, films failing to demonstrate cultural sensitivity, particularly in their depiction of social norms, regional variations, current trends, and diversity, often suffer as a result. Failure to consider these crucial elements can lead to a significant audience disconnect, hindering the film's ability to effectively communicate with the intended demographic. A lack of cultural relevance often signifies a missed opportunity to connect emotionally and intellectually with the target audience, resulting in diminished audience engagement and, consequently, lower box office returns. Understanding and reflecting contemporary cultural nuances is, therefore, critical for a successful Bollywood film.
7. Production Quality
Production quality is a critical element in the success of any film, and its absence is frequently a contributing factor to Bollywood films categorized as flops. Substandard production values, from visuals to sound design, can severely hinder a film's ability to captivate audiences and generate box office revenue. This section examines specific aspects of production quality that, when compromised, frequently result in commercial failure.
- Visuals and Cinematography
Inadequate cinematography, poor camera work, or visually unappealing sets can detract from the overall viewing experience. A film's aesthetic is crucial for attracting and maintaining audience interest. Poorly lit scenes, jarring cuts, or uninspired compositions can quickly diminish engagement. An overly simple or dated visual style might fail to match contemporary expectations. A visually striking film enhances the narrative, whereas a film lacking visual flair can appear dated or poorly produced, affecting audience reception and commercial prospects. This can range from simple set design to the quality of special effects.
- Sound Design and Editing
Substandard sound design, including poor audio mixing, distracting background noise, or a lack of clarity in dialogue, can significantly diminish a film's impact. Poor sound quality and editing can make a film difficult or unpleasant to watch, undermining the narrative's ability to fully engage the audience. A poorly edited soundtrack, or a lack of attention to crucial audio cues, can disrupt the viewer's immersion and detract from the overall emotional experience. This translates into a failure to convey the narrative's intended impact.
- Special Effects and CGI
In contemporary cinema, special effects and CGI play a significant role. Poorly executed special effects can be distracting and detract from the overall narrative experience. Audiences expect a certain level of visual fidelity and realism, particularly in films featuring extensive special effects. When these effects are substandard or poorly integrated, the film can fall short, losing viewers to films with more impressive visual aspects. Ineffective or jarring CGI can often result in audiences perceiving a film as poorly made, leading to negative reviews and reduced box office revenue.
- Production Design and Set Design
Substandard production design, such as poorly designed sets or costumes, can compromise a film's visual appeal and undermine the narrative. The visual presentation of a film reflects its production values. Poorly designed sets, costumes, or props can give the film an amateurish or cheap feel. This perception of low production value can greatly influence audience impressions, hindering the film's ability to resonate with viewers, ultimately impacting its commercial success.
Ultimately, the quality of production significantly impacts audience perception. Films with inadequate production values can fail to create the desired atmosphere, immersive experience, and emotional connection, resulting in poor audience engagement and, consequently, lower box office numbers. These issues, when considered in conjunction with other factors like scriptwriting or marketing, often contribute substantially to the categorization of a film as a commercial failure in the Bollywood film industry.
8. Star Power Miscalculation
Star power, a significant force in Bollywood, can sometimes be a double-edged sword. A miscalculation in leveraging star power can contribute significantly to a film's failure. The perceived star value does not always translate into audience interest or box office success if the film's overall quality falters. This section examines how misjudging the impact of star power can result in commercial disappointment.
- Overreliance on Star Appeal
Films frequently prioritize star power above other crucial aspects, such as compelling storytelling or nuanced performances. While a renowned star may attract initial interest, a weak script or direction can outweigh any pre-existing fan base. The star's charisma alone might not save a film from its inherent shortcomings. This highlights the limited effectiveness of star power as a sole selling point.
- Inadequate Role Alignment
Miscasting or assigning a role that doesn't suit a star's strengths or the character's requirements can significantly affect the film's success. An actor might be renowned for a certain type of role, yet a film's script doesn't exploit these strengths. This mismatch can lead to a perceived disconnect between the star's image and the film's narrative, resulting in a weaker audience connection. Examples show how poorly conceived roles for prominent actors can lead to negative critical reception and low returns at the box office.
- Neglecting Supporting Cast
An overemphasis on a lead star often results in overlooked supporting talent. A lack of supporting roles that complement the lead actor's performance or provide needed narrative depth can compromise the overall impact of the film. A film might have an established star but lack the ensemble support to carry the narrative, ultimately reducing its appeal. This highlights the importance of balancing star presence with ensemble strength.
- Exaggerated Promotional Expectations
Overhyping the star's presence in promotional material can sometimes backfire. If a film relies solely on star power for its success, and that star's appeal is later perceived as inadequate for the movie, the promotional campaign's overemphasis can diminish the film's credibility. This often results in a gap between the pre-release hype and the film's final performance. This highlights the interconnectedness of pre-release promotion and film quality.
In summary, a miscalculation in assessing star power's impact can lead to significant commercial failures in Bollywood. Overreliance on a star's name alone, miscasting, neglecting supporting casts, and excessive pre-release hype can all negate any perceived advantages of star power. A successful film necessitates a balanced approach, where star appeal synergizes with a compelling narrative, skilled direction, and a well-rounded cast to effectively connect with the target audience and succeed commercially.
Frequently Asked Questions about Flop Movies in Bollywood
This section addresses common queries regarding unsuccessful Bollywood films, aiming to clarify misconceptions and provide a more nuanced understanding of the industry's dynamics.
Question 1: What are the primary factors contributing to a Bollywood film's failure?
Answer: Several factors contribute to a film's poor performance at the box office. These encompass aspects such as script quality, directorial decisions, casting choices, marketing strategies, audience disconnect, and production values. A combination of these issues, rather than a single cause, frequently results in a film's commercial failure.
Question 2: Can a film with a star cast still be considered a flop?
Answer: Yes. The presence of established stars does not guarantee box office success. A film's inherent strengths, including compelling storytelling, effective direction, and nuanced performances, are crucial for connecting with the audience and exceeding initial projections. Star power, while influential, is not a standalone determinant of success.
Question 3: How does marketing affect the outcome of a Bollywood film?
Answer: Effective marketing is essential for building pre-release anticipation and driving ticket sales. Inadequate or misdirected marketing efforts can significantly hinder a film's potential. A film's success frequently depends on its ability to reach the intended audience and generate the necessary buzz through strategic communication.
Question 4: Why do some well-reviewed films still underperform at the box office?
Answer: Critical acclaim does not always translate into commercial success. Audience perception and expectations, sometimes influenced by external factors, can deviate from critical opinions. A film's subject matter, genre, or overall appeal might not resonate with the wider public, even with positive reviews.
Question 5: Is cultural relevance a significant factor in Bollywood film success?
Answer: Yes. Films that reflect contemporary cultural values, address relevant issues, and respect diverse regional nuances generally enjoy wider appeal. Conversely, a film disconnected from or insensitive to the cultural context it portrays frequently encounters difficulties connecting with audiences.
Question 6: How does production quality affect a film's performance?
Answer: Production quality, including visuals, sound, and special effects, significantly impacts a film's overall appeal. Poor production values can undermine the narrative and detract from the viewing experience. Audiences often respond favorably to films with meticulous attention to detail, demonstrating a direct link between production quality and commercial success.
In conclusion, understanding the multifaceted reasons behind a Bollywood film's failure necessitates a comprehensive analysis of numerous interwoven factors. These factors extend beyond star power and encompass script quality, directorial vision, audience connection, marketing strategies, and production values. Successful films typically strike a balance across these crucial areas.
The following sections will delve deeper into each of these factors, providing a more in-depth understanding of the complex dynamics that shape the Bollywood film industry.
Tips for Avoiding Bollywood Film Flops
Analyzing prior commercial failures in Bollywood cinema reveals recurring patterns. Understanding these patterns offers valuable insights for filmmakers aiming to create successful productions. By examining the elements frequently associated with unsuccessful films, creators can refine their approaches and increase the likelihood of positive reception.
Tip 1: Prioritize Strong Scriptwriting. A compelling narrative is fundamental. A well-structured plot, relatable characters, and engaging dialogue are essential. Avoid clichs and predictable storylines. A strong script can elevate even a moderately talented cast and crew. Example: Films like Dil Chahta Hai, celebrated for its unique story and character dynamics, contrast with poorly received films featuring repetitive plots and unconvincing dialogue.
Tip 2: Ensure Effective Directorial Vision. Strong direction translates into a cohesive narrative and visual appeal. A director needs to command pacing, scene transitions, and visual style that aligns with the story. Example: Films known for their artistic visual language, like those directed by Satyajit Ray, demonstrate how well-executed direction can enhance a film. Conversely, films lacking a clear directorial vision often suffer from a disjointed narrative.
Tip 3: Accurate Casting Choices. Actors should embody their characters convincingly. Consider an actor's acting range and compatibility with the role. Casting decisions should not solely rely on star power but also prioritize talent and chemistry. Example: Well-received films often exhibit careful casting choices that enhance the narrative, while poorly received films often suffer from miscasting, leading to a disconnect between characters and audiences.
Tip 4: Develop Comprehensive Marketing Strategies. Effective marketing builds anticipation and targets the intended audience. Utilize multiple platforms and engage in strategic pre-release campaigns. Analyze audience response to promotional material. Example: Successful marketing campaigns create buzz and generate excitement, thereby maximizing audience reach. Conversely, inadequate or poorly targeted marketing campaigns often fail to ignite public interest.
Tip 5: Consider Cultural Context. Acknowledge and integrate relevant cultural nuances into the narrative. Represent diverse communities and perspectives authentically. Avoid generalizations or misinterpretations of cultural values. Example: Films that resonate with audiences often reflect sensitivity to cultural diversity, while insensitive portrayals can lead to significant backlash.
Tip 6: Maintain High Production Values. Visuals, sound, and technical aspects of filmmaking are crucial. Invest in quality cinematography, sound design, and editing. A film with excellent production quality conveys a level of professionalism and dedication that appeals to audiences. Example: Films with a high degree of technical proficiency often receive positive reviews, while those exhibiting poor production values may struggle to achieve audience appreciation.
By implementing these strategies, filmmakers can mitigate risks and increase the likelihood of creating engaging and commercially successful films. Failure to heed these points, often found in commercially unsuccessful productions, frequently contributes to the perceived lack of audience connection.
These tips, when applied thoughtfully, provide a framework for creators striving to generate positive audience response and successful box office results. Ongoing analysis of industry trends and audience preferences further refines approaches and enhances the likelihood of achieving commercial success.
Conclusion
The exploration of "flop movies" in Bollywood reveals a complex interplay of factors contributing to commercial failure. Analysis demonstrates that successful films in the industry consistently demonstrate a convergence of strong narrative elements, effective directorial choices, accurate casting, and well-executed marketing strategies. Conversely, a deficiency in any of these areas can significantly diminish a film's box office performance. Critically, the study underscores the importance of cultural sensitivity and alignment with contemporary audience preferences. Films that fail to reflect or engage with these nuances often encounter difficulty connecting with viewers. Poor production values, including subpar visuals, sound, and special effects, also contribute substantially to a film's failure to capture audience attention. Ultimately, the analysis emphasizes that a successful Bollywood film necessitates a nuanced understanding of the intricate interplay between creative vision and audience expectations.
The examination of unsuccessful films offers valuable insights into the evolving landscape of the Indian film industry. By understanding the patterns associated with commercial failures, filmmakers can refine their strategies, potentially leading to a more robust and adaptable industry capable of producing films that connect with wider audiences. Further research into specific case studies and trends can offer even deeper insights into the dynamics of success and failure in the Bollywood market, aiding in the long-term growth and evolution of Indian cinema. This knowledge can inform future production decisions, contributing to the creation of films that effectively address current audience preferences and cultural contexts.
You Might Also Like
Dakota Goyo Height: [Approximate Measurement]Tate Taylor Net Worth 2024: A Deep Dive
Bigg Boss 17: Watch Online In USA - Official Stream
2024 Maharaja Tamil Movie Showtimes - Find Your Seats Now!
Michael Welch Net Worth: 2024 Update & Forbes Ranking